It's been a little over a month since the Vancouver Canucks made the decision to part ways with J.T. Miller, offloading the veteran center in a blockbuster trade with the New York Rangers. That trade effectively put an end to the feud between Miller and Canucks captain Elias Pettersson which had been reported about at length throughout the season.
Since the trade, Miller has absolutely flourished with the Rangers, while Pettersson's season-long woes have not only continued, but gotten worse. Miller has 14 points in 11 games with New York since the trade, having looked more like the 103-point scorer from last season. As for Pettersson, he's recorded just three points in the 10 games since Miller's departure and hasn't scored a single goal in his last 14 games.
In fact, since the trade on Jan. 31, Miller has more points (14) than Pettersson has shots on goal (8). That rings true despite Vancouver coach Rick Tocchet telling the media that the Canucks wanted Pettersson to be more aggressive and take more shots on offense. Meanwhile, since arriving in the Big Apple, Miller has helped reinvigorate a Rangers team that had been performing well below expectations, vaulting them back into the thick of the playoff race.
There's been plenty of discussion among NHL fans in the aftermath of that trade, and many seem to believe the Canucks made a mistake by trading Miller. Despite Miller being 31 years old, five years older than Pettersson, the lack of production from the Swede has been a major concern, prompting fans to suggest Vancouver should've traded him instead of Miller.
This one hurts to tweet:
— Grady Sas (@GradySas) March 3, 2025
J.T. Miller has more points (12) than Elias Pettersson does shots (8) since the Miller trade. 😖 #Canucks https://t.co/AyM8GXId1f
The first 10 games are in the books for J.T. Miller and Elias Pettersson since they parted ways 😳🗽 pic.twitter.com/76MRGdQl9i
— Gino Hard (@GinoHard_) March 3, 2025
JT Miller proving why people shouldn’t listen to certain couch GM’s. It’s all about what a team needs not what will make the team look good on paper. JT is exactly the 1C the Rangers needed, not Elias Pettersson who has more “skill”. #NYR
— Sean Avery Burner (@AveryBurnerAcct) March 4, 2025
pic.twitter.com/hic0AqMxMx
Unreal stat:
— Lafreniere For MVP (@Laf4MVP_) March 4, 2025
JT Miller points since joining the Rangers: 14
Elias Pettersson shots on goal since JT Miller joined the Rangers: 8
🤯🤯🤯#NYR pic.twitter.com/Ug3Ztl3Syv
J.T. Miller > Elias Pettersson
— Lauren🏒 (@Ms_NYRangers) March 4, 2025
Not up for debate. #NYR
Elias Pettersson has 0 goals, 3 pts in 10 games since the JT Miller trade. #Canucks
— NHL Watcher (@NHL_Watcher) March 2, 2025
Hindsight we shouldve kept Horvat, traded Pettersson then and obviously Kept Miller
— Gr8WhiteBUFFalo 💪 (@JRockSmitty8) March 4, 2025
Imagine the return for Petey then and no dumb $11.6 mil tied to us ever
Probably would've won a cup by now
This was just poorly managed all around #Canucks
Everyday I have a good laugh to myself about how the Vancouver Canucks decided to move Miller and keep Pettersson at $11,600,000 until 2032😭😭 pic.twitter.com/Y9wmQDBeAk
— Welcome To Oil Country (@Oil_Country_) March 3, 2025
Traded this guy over Pettersson. Ridiculous. Fire Tocchet, Allvin and Rutherford https://t.co/kKFM6OkYb6
— Julian Medd (@JMedd19) March 3, 2025
There's time for Pettersson to turn things around. After all, he's only two years removed from putting up an impressive 102-point campaign, and he had 89 points in 2023–24 including what was his third consecutive 30-goal season. Still, the decision to move on from Miller hasn't paid dividends for the Canucks, who are at risk of missing out on the playoffs altogether.
Pettersson is signed through the 2031-32 season and collects an AAV of $11.6 million, making him the team's most expensive player. With 35 points in 54 games, the production simply hasn't been there, and his struggles have mounted in the aftermath of Miller's departure.
More of the Latest Sports News
This article was originally published on www.si.com as NHL Fans Think Canucks Messed Up By Trading J.T. Miller Instead of Elias Pettersson.